BLOYL Customer loyalty Platform
Enterprise customer loyalty platform for engagement, promotions, and rewards
The Great Loyalty Program Debate: Are Points and Rewards Still Relevant?
Analyzing the Effectiveness of Points-Based Loyalty Programs in Today’s Consumer Landscape
Table of Contents
TOUCH
01
Introduction: Today’s “Points Fatigue” In a “Sea of Sameness”
TOUCH
02
Debate Part 1: The Case FOR Points-Based Loyalty Programs
TOUCH
03
Debate Part 2: The Case AGAINST Points-Based Loyalty Programs
TOUCH
04
Debate Part 3: Alternative Loyalty Models
02
The Loyalty Landscape is Evolving
Loyalty programs have been a key tool for fostering customer engagement and retention since their inception in the early 1980s. The first major loyalty program, launched by American Airlines in 1981, introduced the concept of earning "points" or "miles" for purchases, which could be redeemed for future travel. This model quickly spread to other industries, including retail and financial services, where it became a cornerstone of customer retention strategies. By the 1990s, points-based systems had expanded into coalition programs, allowing consumers to earn points across multiple brands and creating a more unified and rewarding experience.
Over time, loyalty programs have incorporated digital advancements and data analytics to personalize offerings, but the fundamental concept of points accumulation has remained relatively unchanged. Today, we are witnessing a significant shift in consumer expectations.
So the time is right to ask the question: are points-based reward programs still relevant in consumer marketing today? Let’s have that debate!
The Case for Points-Based Loyalty
Debate Part 1 - The Case FOR Points-Based Loyalty Programs
Key Benefits
1. Psychological or Emotional Commitment
2. Flexibility and Versatility
3. Proven Effectiveness
The Case For Points-Based Loyalty
2. Deliver Value with Flexibility and Versatility
Points-based systems are highly versatile and can be customized to suit various business models, making them a valuable tool across multiple industries, from retail and hospitality to financial services and beyond. The adaptability of points allows them to be aligned with different customer engagement strategies and reward structures, depending on the unique needs and preferences of the target audience. For instance, while a retail brand may use points to reward customers for product purchases or online interactions, a hospitality brand could reward points for bookings, referrals, and special services like spa treatments or other experiences.
This level of customization allows businesses to maintain a consistent framework for rewarding customer engagement while tailoring specific rewards and redemption options to create a more personalized and engaging experience.
As a result, points-based systems have become a go-to choice for brands looking to implement loyalty programs that can evolve along with customer expectations and market trends.
The Case for Points-Based Loyalty
Proven Effectiveness from the Perspective of Professional Researchers
The Starbucks Rewards program attributes 40% of the company’s total sales to loyalty program members, and the program has driven an 11% growth in their user base.
Programs that focus on personalization and delivering individualized experiences can see up to a 12% increase in customer lifetime value (CLV) compared to standard point-based programs.
Top-performing loyalty programs can boost revenue by 15 to 25% annually from engaged customers by increasing either their purchase frequency or basket size or both.
Customers who are emotionally connected to brands have a 306% higher lifetime value than customers who are merely satisfied
Effective loyalty programs can improve customer retention by up to 30%, as consumers who are emotionally engaged are more likely to stay loyal to a brand.
Top-performing loyalty programs can boost revenue by 15 to 25% annually from engaged customers by increasing either their purchase frequency or basket size or both.
The Case Against Points-Based Loyalty
Debate Part 2 - The Case AGAINST Points-Based Loyalty Programs
Key Benefits
1. Complexity and Transparency Issues
2. Points Fatigue and Reduced Engagement
3. Transactional Program Staleness
The Case Against Points-Based Loyalty
2. Points Fatigue and Reduced Engagement
Over time, consumers can experience "points fatigue" if the rewards offered in a loyalty program remain stagnant or if the perceived value of those rewards diminishes.
When customers feel that the points they are earning do not lead to personally meaningful benefits or that the process of accumulating and redeeming points is not worth the effort, they may lose interest in participating. This disengagement can manifest as reduced program participation, fewer repeat purchases, and an overall decline in lifetime value.
Customers are more likely to shift their attention if a loyalty program fails to communicate value to its members or introduce new, compelling rewards. Ultimately, stale programs negatively impact the program's effectiveness and weaken customer relationships with the brand.
Loyalty Alternatives
Debate Part 3 - Alternative Loyalty Models
Key Considerations
1. Cash-Based Rewards
2. Experiential Rewards
3. Values-Based Loyalty
Cash Rewards
Provide immediate utility but often fail to create long-lasting loyalty or emotional attachment to the brand.
Experiential Rewards
Offer memorable experiences that create emotional connections, particularly appealing to millennials and Gen Z consumers, but require active management and can be costly.
Value-Based Loyalty
Programs that align with a customer’s personal values (e.g., sustainability or social responsibility) can significantly enhance brand loyalty, but can be polarizing if too overt.
Hybrid Loyalty Programs
Debate Part 4 - Finding A Middle Ground
Hybrid Loyalty Programs
1. Definition
2. Unified Customer Value
3. Examples
Finding A Middle Ground
1. What Are Hybrid Loyalty Programs?
Hybrid loyalty programs that blend points accumulation with personalized brand interactions, and upgraded rewards opportunities provide a fresh solution that caters to a wide range of consumer preferences and motivations. These programs maintain the simplicity and familiarity of earning and redeeming points, while also offering unique experiences that foster a deeper emotional connection with the brand.
Examples of new point-earning experiences can include:
- Expanded customer profile or survey completion
- Branded content views or interactive games
- Attendance at live events or webinars
- Referrals and reviews/testimonials
- Social advocacy, UGC, and influencer affiliates
By combining the transactional nature of points with more meaningful and engaging (not to mention helpful from a marketing perspective) experiences, hybrid programs can increase satisfaction, boost loyalty, and ensure the program remains relevant and appealing over time.
Finding A Middle Ground
2. Unified Customer Value Delivery
When a company unifies its various value delivery tools - such as rebates, discounts, promotions, loyalty points, and rewards - into a single, cohesive platform, it gains significant advantages in both customer experience and business efficiency. Consolidating these elements enables a more seamless and engaging interaction with customers, as they can access all benefits through a single, integrated system.
For the company, a consolidated platform centralizes data collection and analytics, providing a holistic view of customer behaviors and preferences across all value-delivery mechanisms. With this comprehensive data, brands can identify patterns, personalize offers, and optimize their marketing strategies to increase ROI. Additionally, streamlining multiple programs into one platform reduces operational complexities and costs, enhancing the company’s ability to manage and scale loyalty initiatives efficiently.
Ultimately, unifying these tools enables brands to deliver a more compelling and consistent value proposition that strengthens customer relationships and drives long-term growth.
Hybrid Loyalty Programs
Sephora’s Beauty Insider Program
Sephora’s Beauty Insider program exemplifies a hybrid loyalty approach by combining the traditional points-based rewards model with personalized product recommendations and exclusive experiences tailored to each customer. Members earn points for every purchase, which can be redeemed for a wide range of rewards, from deluxe product samples to one-of-a-kind beauty experiences.
Beyond points, Sephora unifies engagement by offering personalized product suggestions based on customers’ past purchases and preferences, along with access to exclusive events, such as makeup classes or early product launches.
As a result, Sephora’s Beauty Insider program drives higher levels of engagement, satisfaction, and increased spend per customer, demonstrating how combining transactional and experiential elements can create a more compelling loyalty proposition.
Hybrid Loyalty Programs
Marriott Bonvoy
Members in the Marriott Bonvoy program earn points for hotel stays and other purchases across Marriott’s extensive portfolio of brands, which can then be redeemed for free nights, room upgrades, and travel packages. However, Marriott Bonvoy goes beyond the transactional aspects of points by offering members exclusive experiences through its Moments program, such as private culinary events, VIP concert access, and curated local tours.
Additionally, the program provides status-based benefits like late checkouts, personalized services, and access to lounges, which enhance the customer’s overall experience.
This combination of traditional point-based rewards with exclusive experiences and personalized perks makes Marriott Bonvoy a well-rounded program that not only incentivizes purchases but also builds long-term loyalty by catering to customers’ aspirations and lifestyle preferences.
.png?width=300&name=marriott-bonvoy%20(1).png)